The Chartership Forum

ICE / Initial development

Career Appraisal: who it is for

Check whether Career Appraisal is appropriate and what to confirm before starting.

In this guide
LEARNING GUIDE

Use this material to examine your own work. Confirm current requirements, forms and dates with ICE before applying.

ICE identifies circumstances in which candidates should use another route. Check that Career Appraisal applies to you before spending months preparing a submission.

Experience suited to Career Appraisal

Career Appraisal can suit engineers with ten or fifteen years of work outside an approved scheme; those returning after an interrupted Training Agreement; engineers who moved into civil or infrastructure work from another discipline; and IEng MICE engineers seeking the additional Chartered responsibilities through a shorter top-up report. A partial completion record can help a returning candidate, but is not essential.

Checking the experience first

The attributes and required level remain the same. Check that you can explain your own decisions in each of the seven areas. Where you cannot, use the gap analysis to plan relevant experience over the next six months before submitting.

Questions to ask yourself

  1. Has ICE confirmed my educational base for the grade I am applying at?

    This is a stated requirement of the route, not something the assessors will work around.

  2. Am I currently on any scheme that blocks this?

    A Training Agreement or mentor-supported registration you have forgotten about will stop the application.

  3. Am I applying at the right grade?

    The report is written against a stated level. Reworking it afterwards is a substantial rewrite, not an edit.

  4. Do I have three years of CPD records?

    The Career Appraisal requires a personal development record covering at least the last three years. If you have kept nothing, that is the constraint on your timing.

Before you decide this is your route

Official sources

Selected publisher pages were rechecked in September 2026. Other source records were last checked in July 2026. Open the latest official document before relying on a requirement.