The Chartership Forum

Structural dynamics / tutorial

A frame that is allowed to yield

Ductility demand, the strength it buys, and the displacement it does not reduce.

Return to tutorials
Teaching basis and review status

These are educational models and exercises. Check their assumptions before using the results. The full technical content and every diagram have not yet been independently verified.

Concrete and steel calculations retain their stated first-generation Eurocode teaching basis. Use the standards and amendments specified for your project; do not mix generations without an appropriate design basis.

Read the lesson register and outstanding review notes

A single-storey steel frame is designed to yield in a severe event rather than to resist it elastically. The detailing has been checked and a ductility of 3.2 is reliably available.

Establish what that buys in strength, what it costs in displacement, and how much energy the frame absorbs in doing it. The third answer is the one that explains why ductile detailing is worth its trouble; the second is the one most often forgotten.

  • Lateral stiffness 9.5 MN/m
  • Yield force 420 kN
  • Post-yield stiffness ratio α = 0.03
  • Elastic period 0.75 s

Practice

What is the yield displacement, in millimetres?

Practice

At a ductility demand of 3.2, what peak displacement does the frame reach, in millimetres?

Practice

Using the equal-energy rule appropriate below the corner period, what strength reduction factor does μ = 3.2 give?

Practice

How much energy does one full symmetric cycle at that ductility dissipate, in kJ? Use the elastic–perfectly plastic expression.

Strength down by a factor of 2.3; displacement unchanged at 141 mm; energy dissipation up by a factor of eighteen. The behaviour factor is a strength reduction and nothing more, and every drift-sensitive detail in the building sees no benefit from it whatever.